Warhammer Underworlds is a fantasy skirmish wargame, or at least that's the easy way of describing it. It's actually also a deck builder card game, a miniatures wargame, an experiment in rules delivery, and a clever business model. I've only been playing Warhammer Underworlds since Wintermaw was released in 2024, and even then not often. I don't have the opportunity to play a definitively competitive 2-player game often, but it's a good game and, more importantly, very interesting game design. This is my review of Warhammer Underworlds as a game system.
A potential problem with Games Workshop's method of selling miniature wargaming is that most people have finite storage space. To engage with Games Workshop's properties, however, you kinda have to buy miniatures, because that's primarily what they produce and promote. You can temper purchases of miniatures with books for a while, but eventually you see something inspiring in the store or in a magazine, and then you want to paint miniatures and play with them. Skirmish games are a big help, though. You get a whole playable "army" in just 8 miniatures. Everybody has room for 8 miniatures a year. Warhammer Underworlds is a skirmish game in the Warhammer: Age of Sigmar (AoS) setting.
This is why I chose it as my way to interact with that setting, in fact. I knew I didn't have the money or the space or the time to start collecting a whole AoS army, so boxed games like Cursed City and Warhammer Underworlds seemed like a great way to get just the miniatures I needed for a specific game scenario. I could add a few character models here and there, because I do love picking up a fun character model in a blister pack from time to time, but primarily the armies are set.
The clever thing about Warhammer Underworlds is that there are warbands for Warhammer Underworlds that you can buy in a box. They come with character cards with all the stats required to use that warband in a Warhammer Underworlds set. In other words, you buy a Warhammer Underworlds box to get the board, dice, rules, cards, tokens, and 2 warbands, but you can swap out those warbands with other miniatures in the product line. For example, I bought the Wintermaw boxed game and got a Brethren of the Bolt warband and a Skinnerkin warband, and later when I purchased a kit of Kamandora's Blades for my Middle-earth Strategy Battle Game campaign (I use them as a little Far Harad army), I was able to use those models in games of Wintermaw. (Actually, Kamandora's Blades is for a previous edition of Warhammer Underworlds, but minor differences in presentation didn't bother me.)
It's a really clean way of providing product. The warbands are small, so you're not committing to building, painting, and storing a huge army. You don't have to develop an army list, because the box is the army. You don't have to read a big complex rulebook and lots of codexes or warscrolls or whatever they're called in AoS, because everything you need was in the starter box.
A key component to the Warhammer Underworlds game is a deck of cards you can use to give an impromptu bonus to your army. A base set of cards come in the game box, and expansion sets are sold as separate products. If this sounds like it's Magic: The Gathering (MTG) mixed in with a miniatures wargame, it definitely isn't, which actually took me by surprise because that's how a lot of people were talking about it, at least in my local Warhammer community. The cards in Warhammer Underworlds aren't generally direct attacks or bombastic events, they're more like sudden exceptions to established rules. Changing a rule to suit your own goals can be a powerful ability, but it's not like summoning a creature in MTG. If anything, it's more like Arkham Horror: Living Card Game, where you have a deck of "new" rules about how your character works in the game, but which rule comes into active play depends on the luck of the draw and what resources you have available.
Deck building in Warhammer Underworlds is actually a clever inversion of the Army Detachment rules in 40k. Instead of selecting an army rule and a detachment, and then desperately memorising those rules before you go to the table, you build a pool of potential rules into a card deck. You don't have to remember them, because they're on cards, and anyway you don't know which card you're going to draw next. Once you draw a card that's relevant to your current game state, and advantageous for your immediate goal, you can play the card from your hand. The card might allow you to take an extra action after you make a successful charge move, or to draw in support from soldiers too far away to normally provide support, and so on.
The strange thing about the card component of the game, for me, is that cards are played after miniature activation. For me, there's a little bit of a disconnect between the process of playing a card and playing your army. I had expected for the cards to set me up for something really cool on the battlefield, but instead the cards usually just gently shift the context of the board state. This can still be powerful, technically, but it almost never feels like a surprise to me. I find myself often explaining that no, actually I can do a thing, because I put that card down at the end of my previous turn, remember? Maybe I'm just thinking about it backwards, and maybe I'm doing that because I'd been incorrectly primed to expect power plays like you see in MTG, but the cards in Underworlds rarely feel like power-ups to me, and instead come across as convenient opportunities to slightly move a goal post, or to steal a base when nobody's looking. It's a nice bonus to have, but if this were a video game I don't think it would get any sparkles or cool particle effects.
I do admire what the cards represent, in terms of the game's design. By inventing a bunch of context-dependent rules and putting them into a shuffled deck, the game no longer relies on the players to know any army rules. All you need to know while playing Warhammer Underworlds is the turn sequence (which is over-complex, to be fair). Each miniature has a character card, so you have rules specific to each miniature in front of you at all times. Situational modifiers come from the card deck, and the only ones that matter are those currently in play. You don't have to memorise rules because the rules change as you draw and play cards.
Getting started is, thanks to the cards, relatively simple. Buy a box, or an army and a deck, read the rulebook once, and start playing. The trade-off is that each game is full of exceptions and special conditional rules that you may have never seen before. With every turn, your brain must cycle from army tactics to board state to active rules and then back to board state. In that way this isn't a casual game by any means. It's a demanding game that requires constant concentration. I have to admit that I find it pretty exhausting.
In my opinion, Warhammer Underworlds is the most competitive wargames produced by Games Workshop, which I hadn't considered when buying Wintermaw. Especially because the cards are constantly changing the rules of the game, there aren't really any binary decisions for the opposing army. You can't relegate it to an AI or a games master. The design of the game requires a human actively making decisions to defeat you because the game itself lacks the rules to ensure your defeat on its own.
By contrast, Warhammer 40,000 or Middle-earth Strategy Battle Game are games that actively try to defeat you, regardless of your army (Order, Chaos, Good, or Evil.) The rules require the opposing army, whether it's a human opponent, a games master, or choices you make solo, to find a target and to attack. When the attack happens, army rules and detachment rules are triggered to optimise it efficacy. The games play the other army, maybe not amazingly but given the randomness of dice and a few good universal rules, even a human playing on auto-pilot can deal your army some damage.
Warhammer Underworlds can't do that. The opposing army can move and attack, and that could be bad for your warband, but ultimately extra rules must be put into play.
Being hard-coded as a competitive game isn't a bad thing, but it's not a good match for the way I play my wargames. I'm a narrative, and usually a co-op, wargamer. I like to play with friends, not against friends, but Warhammer Underworlds isn't the game for co-op.
Games Workshop only has more settings than you might realise. The obvious major split is fantasy and science fantasy: AoS and 40k. But within science fantasy, there's 40k, Horus Heresy, and Necromunda. Within fantasy, there's AoS and Old World (original Warhammer), and Blood Bowl, and Middle-earth. So it's a lot. And the bothersome thing about that is they're all really appealing.
Worse still, Games Workshop does a really great job of developing its settings. I speak from experience when I say that you go years without even understanding what a wargame is but still be a fan of Warhammer, it's that well developed.
My point is, I do find Warhammer: Age of Sigmar appealing. and I do want to explore that world and its characters and factions. But I don't realistically have room in my gaming life for yet another game system, much less money, time, or space to build yet more armies.
Warhammer Underworlds is a nice solution. Cursed City was a good way to start, and while I like the limited scope of that game it does constrain your exploration of the Mortal Realms to exactly one city. Warhammer Underworlds is open ended. You can buy a handful of miniatures, put them on a hex map, and play. I appreciate that it's a tidy way to participate in the Warhammer: Age of Sigmar setting without getting lost in it.
Wintermaw is the first Warhammer Underworlds set I purchased, and it'll be my last. I enjoy Warhammer Underworlds as a game design exercise, but for my particular (current) style of gaming it's not a great fit. It's a great fit for some gamers though, and I can see why it was widely praised as one of the best ways to engage with miniature wargaming.
In future, I might try Spearhead or maybe I'll just continue looking at AoS from afar, buying the odd kit to re-purpose in my Middle-earth games. Currently, with my wargames being an unholy mix of roleplay and tabletop tactics, Warhammer Underworlds isn't a good fit for me. Despite not playing it often, however, I do recommend Warhammer Underworlds. I think it's an interesting way to get into fantasy wargaming. It's no Middle-earth Strategy Game, of course, but it's a good time in the Mortal Realms with some great miniatures.
All images in this post copyright Games Workshop.